How Long Can You Refrigerate Cheesecake?

Cheesecake keeps rather well, which is one of the many reasons we love it. But, it is made with cream cheese and eggs, so there are limits, and it is worth knowing where they are.

So, the short answer is about five to seven days in the fridge for a homemade one. Now, let us go through the details.

How Long Does Cheesecake Last In The Fridge?

A homemade baked cheesecake will be at its best for five to seven days, kept covered and properly cold. No-bake versions are a little more delicate, so we would eat those within about four or five days.

We have a longer piece on how long cheesecake lasts in the refrigerator if you want the detail. Store-bought cheesecake usually lasts slightly longer thanks to preservatives, but go by the date on the box rather than guessing. And, once you have cut into it, cover the exposed edge, because that is where it dries out first.

How Long Does It Last After Defrosting?

Once a frozen cheesecake has thawed in the fridge, treat it exactly like a fresh one. So, that gives you roughly three to five days, depending on how long it had already been sitting before it went into the freezer.

But, please do not refreeze it. The texture goes grainy, and you lose the smoothness that makes a cheesecake worth eating in the first place.

How Long Can It Sit Out?

This is the one that really matters, so we want to be clear about it. Two hours at room temperature, and no more.

Cream cheese and eggs are exactly the kind of thing bacteria are fond of, and they multiply quickly once the cake warms up. So, if a cheesecake has been sitting on the table all afternoon at a party, it goes in the bin, however painful that is. And in genuinely hot weather, that window drops to about an hour.

You will occasionally see it claimed that cheesecake keeps for days unrefrigerated. It does not, and that advice is worth ignoring.

How Do You Know If It Has Gone Bad?

Your nose is the best tool here. A spoiled cheesecake smells sour and stale, like milk that has turned, rather than fresh and dairy-ish.

Then, look at it. Mold, dark patches, or a slimy film on the surface all mean it is finished. The crust going soggy is another sign, and so are the edges turning brown and dry.

And, one thing to remember. A slight tang is completely normal, because that is just the cream cheese doing its job. Tangy is not the same as sour. But, if it smells wrong or looks wrong, do not taste it to check, just throw it out.

Can You Freeze It Instead?

Yes, and cheesecake freezes better than most desserts. Wrap it well, and it will keep for about two months without much loss of quality.

So, thaw it overnight in the fridge rather than on the counter, and it will come back almost exactly as it went in.

Watch This Video: