Best Cheesecake In Long Island

By Griselda M., last updated on September 19, 2024

Wondering what’s the best cheesecake in the Long Island area? We have come with a top 7 best cheesecake ever. Keep on reading and check them out!

So we went to try some of the popular ones and what the locals would call the irresistible cheesecakes in the city. We really think you should go try them out and let us know if you agree with us or not. Down for it?

Best Cheesecake in Long Island

That’s right, the Cheesecakes World crew and I went for a walk. We did a cheesecake tour throughout Long Island and we were a little surprised. Sometimes we overestimate popular places and minimize the not-so-popular or places that are not known.

It’s not just New York that has a wealth of amazing food places. Long Island can easily hold its own, too. People would ride miles to get to a magical place and get an astonishing dish, I’ve done it and I’m sure you had.

So yes, we went to do our work as culinary critics and we found some hidden and wonderful spots, those places that only locals reach. It’s worth getting out of the comfort zone of continuing to go to The Cheesecake Factory. To clarify, we have included them in the list so that you can compare them all.

In this list, we added a few desserts spots that have the greatest desserts, not only cheesecakes. You may have already heard of some of these, take a look and leave a comment in case you have. We totally recommend you go to all of them if possible so you can taste them all and compare.

What we did was we ordered a different cheesecake and shared it with each other. For instance, we could try the variety. So there are no excuses, you now know the secret to expand your sweet palate.

Cheesecake Spots

Spot #1: The Cheesecake Spot

The host of this place is a pretty nice old lady with a big smile on her face that welcomes you to come back. In other words, the menu reaffirms it. Its menu consists of single cheesecakes, mini cheesecakes, cheesecake bites, and 9″ cheesecakes.

And the flavors are:

• Apple Cinnamon
• Banana Puddin
• Blueberry Swirl
• Banana Straw Swirl
• Cookies N Cream
• Hot Chocolate
• Peach Swirl
• Sweet Potato

Spot #2: Mr. Bill’s Cheesecakes

Likewise, if you’re looking for freshness dessert bite, this is certainly the place. Considered by locals as a hidden gem, Mr. Bill’s Cheesecakes has a sugar-free option for many people who are on the Atkins, Keto diet, etc. Similarly, they have mini, small, medium, and large versions.

This place will most definitely be your go-to place when you are craving cheesecake! The flavors are:

• Regular Cheesecake with Topping. You can choose from: strawberry, pineapple, cherry, and blueberry. Sugar-free version.
• Oreo
• Canoli Cream Cheese. Sugar-free version.
• Chambord Raspberry. Sugar-free version.
• Turtle: Caramel swirl with pecans and chocolate fudge. Sugar-free version.
• Chocolate Swirl. Sugar-free version.
• Red Velvet: Icing and chocolate chips on top.
• Reeses
• Amaretto with Nuts. Sugar-free version.

Spot #3: Jonathan Lord Cheesecake

I can’t adequately put into words how tender and fluffy the cheesecake I tried was. But in short, the box says it all:

A taste of Heaven on Earth.

After that, I can say that in my personal opinion, this was my favorite one.

The flavors are:

• Classic
• Triple Chocolate
• Velvet Ribbon
• Strawberry Swirl
• Fudge Marble
• Amaretto
• Cookie Crunch
• Raspberry Fudge
• Key Lime

Spot #4: Holey Moses Cheesecake

This fabulous place makes seasonal cheesecakes. They have an extensive variety and the shop smells like heaven! In conclusion, you have to try it.

The flavors are:

• Original New York. Gluten-free and sugar-free versions.
• Oreo Cookie
• Key Lime
• Lemon
• Amaretto
• Irish Creme
• Chocolate Mousse
• Chocolate Marble
• Chocolate Chip
• Heath bar Crunch
• Snickers
• White Russian
• Pumpkin
• Strawberry
• Cherry
• Raspberry

Spot #5: The Cheesecake Factory

This is practically the most popular cheesecake spot not only in New York but in the whole country. This place has the most extensive menu of them all. It’s a great option for take-out and pick-up.

The cheesecake flavors are:

• Original
• Strawberry
• Chocolate and Caramel with Snickers
• Pineapple Upside-down
• Celebration – Vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate
• Caramel Apple
• Very Cherry Ghirardelli Chocolate
• Low-licious Original. Gluten-free and sugar-free versions.
• Low-licious with Strawberries.
• Cinnabon. Cinnamon Swirl.
• Godiva Chocolate
• Coconut Cream
• Salted Caramel
• Oreo Dream Extreme
• Toasted Marshmellow S’mores Galore
• Adam’s Peanut Butter Cup Fudge Ripple
• Ultimate Red Velvet
• Reese’s Peanut Butter Chocolate
• Dulce de Leche Caramel
• White Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
• Mango Key Lime
• Banana Cream
• Lemon Raspberry Cream
• Chocolate Mousse
• Chocolate Tuxedo Cream
• Lemon Meringue
• Hershey’s Chocolate Bar
• 30th Aniversary Chocolate. It contains layers of the Original cheesecake, fudge, and chocolate truffle cream.
• Vanilla Bean
• Tiramisu
• Key Lime
• Caramel Pecan Turtle
• Pumpkin
• Pumpkin Pecan

Spot #6: Sugarberry Bakery

Meanwhile, if you’re looking for an outdoor seating spot this is the pur-fect place! It’s a lovely place for yummy cheesecakes and cafe au lait. They can also make personalized cheesecakes.

Moreover, this meaning you can schedule a reservation to celebrate your best friend’s birthday or take your mom for a coffee and a slice of cheesecake while enjoying one another. Is a quiet and cozy place to talk.

The cheesecake flavors are:

• Baklava
• Berry
• Caramel
• Chocolate
• Creme Brulee
• New York
• Oreo
• Red Velvet
• Strawberry
• Sugar-free
• Pumpkin

Spot #7: Whistle Stop Bake Shop

If you want the best cheesecake around, go to Whistle. This cute place has been the locals’ favorite since the 70s. The first little spot opened as a tiny store in the Oceanside Railroad in June 1977.

Subsequently, the next year -1978-, the New York Daily News published a survey about them named:

Legging it after cheesecake.

These are the flavors:

• Chocolate Swirl
• Triple Chocolate
• Chocolate Chip
• Black and White
• Strawberry
• Blueberry
• Pineapple
• Cherry
• Lemon
• Amaretto
• Raspberry
• Snickers
• Apple Crumb
• Dulce de Leche
• Oreo
• Irish Cream
• Pumpkin -seasonal-
• Egg Nog
• Sugar-free

To sum up…

Firstly, let us tell you that this Top 7 was designed and followed by foodies and pastry chefs of the staff. Secondly, know that it was very difficult to find a winner among them. Moreover, they all have great taste!

Consequently, the members of the staff were having a disagreement with some of the cheesecakes. But it is human to know that each of us has different tastes and preferences. However, most of us managed to agree on this top 7 list.

I hope you liked it and please, go try them out and live the experience in your mouth. Leave us a comment if you do!