How To Know When A Cheesecake Is Done Baking?

So, the two mistakes we see most often go in opposite directions, and both come down to bad timing rather than a bad recipe.

Pulling It Too Early

This one usually happens because the whole cake still looks glossy and wet, so it gets left in “just a few more minutes” over and over. But a cheesecake with a properly set edge and a small 2 to 3 inch wobble in the center is already done, the shine you are seeing is normal, not a sign of raw batter underneath.

Leaving It In Too Long

The opposite mistake, waiting for the center to stop moving entirely. Once that happens the eggs have overcooked, and what follows is usually a cracked top, a drier texture, and a curdled look at the very edges where it touched the hot pan longest. There is no fixing that in the oven, only covering it up after with a topping.

What Actually Works

Well, we go by the wobble first, then confirm with a thermometer if we are unsure, about 150 degrees Fahrenheit in the center. And once it is out, resist the urge to judge it right away, it firms up considerably just sitting on the counter before it even reaches the fridge.

So, watch the center, trust the thermometer over your eyes when they disagree, and give it time before deciding it went wrong.

Watch This Video: